Legacy Journal Book vs Digital: Comparison Guide 2025
Legacy journals represent the most meaningful inheritance you can leave your family—stories that create priceless connections across generations.
There are multiple approaches to creating a legacy journal, and it can be hard to decide which best matches your needs. There may be options you haven’t even considered yet. Understanding what each delivers and what they require from you is essential before committing your precious time and memories.
We’re comparing the three most popular legacy journal approaches to help you create a legacy of stories your family will genuinely treasure.
Jump to section:
Why Create a Family Legacy Journal in the First Place
It’s worth pausing to consider what drives families to preserve their stories before we explore the different ways to do it.
"Unlike wealth, there is an infinite value in legacy."
— Criss Jami
- Will they know your story? — From childhood adventures to career milestones and retirement discoveries, your life experiences deserve to be preserved rather than forgotten.
- Will family stories get lost forever? — You might be the last person who remembers stories about your own parents or grandparents – stories that connect your family’s past to its future.
- Will they remember the real you? — Beyond photos and brief memories, legacy journals ensure your grandchildren know your personality, humour, and what made you unique.
- What insights could help them? — Members of your family will face challenges in life, and the lessons you’ve learned about relationships, careers, and enjoying life to the full can offer them guidance in their hour of need.
- How do you create lasting connections? — Well-crafted stories have the power to connect you to future generations of your family, help them know you better and make them more aware of their family roots.
Consider these questions as we explore different legacy journal options—different approaches provide different levels of benefits.
Your memories, their legacy—keep family history alive.
Traditional Paper Legacy Journals – The Classic Choice
These are the guided journals you’ll find in bookshops and online; check out DucanandStone’s legacy journal to see how they work. They provide structured templates with questions organised around themes like family, childhood, love, adventures, and advice. You write your answers by hand, add a few photos and give it to your family as a keepsake that explores your life’s key stories.
What paper legacy journals offer
- Simple approach — Follow written templates with no technology required, just grab a pen and start writing.
What you’ll miss out on with handwritten books
- Generic questions that don’t fit your life — Standardised prompts can’t capture what made your life unique, leaving significant gaps in your story.
- Space restrictions — When you fill the allocated lines, your story must end abruptly, regardless of how much more you wanted to share.
- Fact-focused rather than story-rich — Many prompts emphasise basic details (birthplaces, family trees) rather than the meaningful stories that reveal who you are.
- No question customisation — You can’t modify prompts that don’t suit you or add the questions you wish they’d asked.
- Missing multimedia memories — No way to include the videos, voice recordings, or extensive photo collections that bring stories to life.
- Single copy limitation — Only one family member can inherit this physical book, potentially creating family disappointment.
- Irreplaceable risk — Unlike digital formats, there’s no backup copy if your journal gets damaged in a fire, flood, or simply misplaced during a house move.
- No revision possibility — Mistakes, forgotten details, or new perspectives can’t be incorporated once you’ve filled in the pages.
- Limited ongoing engagement — Such books often get read once with enthusiasm, then get forgotten, gathering dust on a bookshelf.
When paper journals are your best option
- No tech skills needed — If you don’t like using computers, handwritten journals offer a familiar and comfortable approach.
- Basic story capture — They are perfect for capturing the generic details throughout different phases of life, without delving into more detailed stories.
- Minimal investment — At around $30, you don’t have much to lose.
Digital-to-Print Services — Professional Books About Individuals
Digital-to-print services like Storyworth and Remento offer a middle ground between paper journals and fully digital platforms.
Storyworth sends weekly email prompts that you answer by writing or dictating, while Remento takes a voice-first approach where you record your responses and AI transforms them into written stories. After a year of storytelling, both create beautiful printed books that make great legacy gifts.
How services like Storyworth and Remento work
- Comprehensive story capture — You can document stories about any aspect of your life, from childhood memories to career highlights.
- Extensive prompt libraries — Storyworth offers 500+ curated questions while Remento provides expert-crafted prompts developed by professional storytellers.
- Family collaboration features — Both allow family members to suggest questions, with Remento offering additional features like real-time reactions and encouragement as stories are shared.
- Voice recording capabilities — Storyworth recently added basic speech-to-text dictation, while Remento’s “Speech-to-Story” AI technology transforms spoken words into polished narratives that match your speaking style.
- Professional book presentation — Storyworth creates 6″x9″ books (colour or black/white options), while Remento produces larger 8″x10″ books on heavier paper designed for longevity.
- Multimedia integration — Both blend text with photos, though Remento’s books include QR codes that link to your original voice recordings, letting future generations hear your actual voice.
- Flexible story length — Unlike physical journals with limited lines, each story can be as detailed as you want (within printing constraints).
The limitations of printed legacy books
- Expensive for multiple copies — Basic packages include only one book, making it costly if several family members want their own copy. And if you’re going to create several legacy books for different family members, the cost can really add up.
- Individual storyteller focus — Both services centre on one person’s story per book, missing the interconnected nature of family experiences and relationships that shape our lives.
- Print format restrictions — No videos, audio files, documents, or interactive maps can be included in the final printed book.
- Page count constraints — Despite digital creation, unlimited photos and stories can’t all fit in one printed volume.
- Static end result — Just like handwritten journals, even professionally designed books often get forgotten on shelves after initial excitement.
- Can’t be updated — Once printed, you can’t add new stories or insights—but your life continues beyond publication…
Why custom-printed books appeal to families
- Professional gift quality — Beautiful physical books with glossy photos and polished text make impressive keepsakes and presents.
- Question flexibility — Extensive prompt libraries help your family identify interesting questions that actually fit your life experiences.
- Completion satisfaction — It’s a finite project you can cross off your to-do list with a tangible result to show for your efforts.
Digital Family Legacy Journals – The Ongoing Family Legacy
Unlike the previous options that focus on individual storytelling, digital family legacy journals represent a fundamental shift in how families preserve their stories.
Shared journal services like Simirity, Day One and Journey transform legacy creation from a solitary retirement project into an ongoing family venture. Rather than waiting until retirement to recall distant memories, your kids and grandkids can capture their experiences as they happen. This creates far richer, more detailed stories that families can enjoy and preserve for generations.
What digital legacy journals offer
- Chronological life timeline — Stories connect to dates, giving your family a proper sequence of events, with flexible dating options when exact dates aren’t remembered.
- Unlimited storytelling space — Create countless stories with no page limits or space restrictions to constrain your memories.
- Rich multimedia capabilities — Combine text, photos, videos, voice recordings, maps, and documents to bring your stories fully to life.
- Flexible prompted storytelling — Access hundreds of great ideas for stories, but freely create your own on any topic that catches your imagination.
- Universal family access — Everyone can participate through websites or apps, turning legacy preservation into a shared family experience.
Potential drawbacks to consider
- No physical book — While there are options to export stories and print, digital stories are best appreciated online due to their inclusion of interactive maps, videos, voice recordings and more.
- Technology learning curve — These are more technically demanding than the previous options. If you’re tech-savvy enough to browse the Internet or send emails, you should be okay.
- Ongoing commitment expectations — While you could treat it as a one-time project, the platform works best as a continuous family storytelling venture. Regular family engagement is what brings legacy stories back into daily conversations instead of letting them fade into the background.
- Family onboarding required — Relatives need to create accounts and connect digitally, which is more complex than simply taking a book down from a shelf.
Why you might find digial journals appealing
- Multi-generational participation — Rather than a solo project, sharing life stories becomes an engaging family venture where you all get to discover new aspects of each other’s lives.
- Ongoing story development — While other legacy options only focus on the past, digital journaling continues growing with new stories throughout your life.
- Richer stories captured in real time — so many details are lost when you recall old events. When your family capture their experiences in real time, the details and emotions make them even more special.
- Two-way family communication — Retired grandparents consistently report that learning about their children’s and grandchildren’s daily lives becomes their favourite benefit of a ‘family’ journal over an individual one.
- Strengthened family bonds — Family storytelling naturally creates deeper connections as relatives discover surprising new aspects of each other’s experiences and perspectives.
Capture your family’s history before it’s too late.
Do These Options Address Your Legacy Questions?
Let’s return to those five key questions and honestly assess how each legacy option delivers on what matters most to families.
Will they know your story?
- Paper journals: Limited space means constraining a lifetime of experiences into the allocated lines on each page.
- Printed books: Better, but still constrained by page count and limited to sharing stories through text and images alone.
- Digital journals: Unlimited space for endless stories, with a variety of media files that bring both you and your experiences to life.
Will family stories get lost forever?
- Paper journals: Only capture your story—ancestral stories and those about extended family remain unpreserved unless you create a separate book for every family member.
- Printed books: Same limitation—focused on individual storytelling rather than including other family members in the narrative.
- Digital journals: Everyone can contribute, from grandparents to grandchildren, and you can even add stories about ancestors. They all live together in one comprehensive family archive.
Will they remember the real you?
- Paper journals: Handwriting offers personality, but pales in comparison to other media like videos and voice recordings.
- Printed books: Professional looking, but perhaps too polished? When contributors edit their stories heavily, they may inadvertently remove authentic character traits.
- Digital journals: By pairing text with authentic voice recordings and videos, your family experiences the real you rather than a watered-down version.
What insights could help them?
- Paper journals: The combination of generic prompts and limited writing space means your most valuable life lessons are unlikely to be captured.
- Printed books: Far better for sharing what you’ve learned, but once confined to a book, these insights aren’t easy to find when people need them most.
- Digital journals: Not only can you share your insights, but family members can easily search for guidance when they need it. In Simirity, we’ve dedicated an entire section to preserving and accessing family wisdom.
How do you create lasting connections?
- Paper journals: Your handwritten stories may be lovely to read, but if nobody picks the book off the shelf, they will fail to connect with others.
- Printed books: Just like with handwritten notes, they risk being forgotten over time.
- Digital journals: These are living projects with ongoing contributions that ensure regular family engagement. Your legacy stories sit alongside present-day experiences, and features like story anniversaries ensure your memories remain active in family life.
When our family was evaluating these questions, we concluded that digital journals would serve our needs better than printed books. But existing platforms were designed for individual storytelling, not family connection—which is why we built Simirity.
Why We Built Simirity – A Personal Family Story
My interest in capturing family stories came about when my parents suffered unexpected and serious health issues. We felt that exploring the stories from their past would be a great way to preserve their experiences and have fun conversations that would strengthen family connections. This is our story.
When we looked at digital journaling options at the time, platforms like Day One and Journey offered individual diary experiences but no family sharing capabilities. Even today, while they’ve added shared journal features, they feel more focused on personal reflection than family connection through storytelling.
For them, the emphasis seemed to be on building an archive of stories. For us, we wanted to enhance our family life as we built that archive. It’s a subtle difference, but it’s the difference between preserving memories and actually using those memories to make the family feel closer.
Want to understand how family-focused journaling differs from individual-focused platforms? Read our comparison here.
That’s how Simirity was born—as a digital journal built from the ground up to address what families actually need: not just story preservation, but genuine connection through storytelling.
Today, our family feels more connected than ever. By sharing authentic stories, I’ve discovered so much about my parents that I never knew, leading to conversations that would never have happened in our regular calls. Some of those moments have become incredibly precious to me—the conversations I value most from our entire experience.
I wish the same for your family—the joy of really knowing each other.
